One of the best, no - THE best - coffeeshop I've ever hung out in happens to be directly across the hall from my design studio (did you know I had a design business? yep, I do...www.playdesignwork.com).
It's called Montana Coffee and it's one of those rare "businesses" that feels so friendly and comfortable that you don't even mind spending twenty bucks everytime you walk in the door. The owners and employees have become friends, the coffee is fantastic, they serve me sourdough toast with loads of butter every morning AND there's an awesome mural of old-time Montana, complete with an angry grizzly bear. It's a gem and the cornerstone of our developing downtown Minneapolis neighborhood.
This week, we found out that the owners had sold Montana Coffee to a church group. The group already conducts two Sunday evening "services" there, the kind with a sermon on TV, soothing acoustic guitars and singers rapping enthusiastically about the awesome love of Jesus. It's pretty low-key and hasn't caused much controversy. But the announcement that this group planned to actually BUY the coffeeshop, add a Weds. night service and possibly stop serving wine and beer has caused total freak-outedness among hard-core patrons and those of us with businesses in the same building. We have much love for Montana.
Now, all of this puts me, fellow crazy Jesus lover + fellow crazy Montana Coffee lover, in a potentially uncomfortable position. As much of a disciple as I try to be, I have to agree with Nairobi Paul's comment that "there are some good things about Christians being in business-but some bad things when they try to Christianize things that maybe shouldn't be." Paul is also a fellow crazy Jesus lover - a missionary in Africa, in fact. We Christians know that this distinction places him WAY high on the Get Into Heaven list and makes him an authority on All Things Holy (major sarcasm intended...a subject for another post!)
But I think his point is that many Christian businesses interpret the call to "meet people where they're at" in ways that contribute to the stereotype of the present day evangelist - ways that put people off and do more to close ears and hearts than to spark a curiousity about Jesus. And ways that don't contribute to the healthy bottom line necessary to run a successful business. So everyone loses.
That's my fear for and of these new coffeeshop owners. I've read their website, which was sent to me by one of my seething studio-mates who is very concerned about working next door to a church. She has her own set of beliefs and does not want to be dealing with a group of people that, in her words, "are basically telling me that I'm going to hell." That is her experience and view of Christianity, and I'm sure many people share it. I did, before my own uninvited but ultimately undeniable personal introduction to Jesus (Also a subject for another post...yah, yah, but I've got to be in the right mood for that one!)
My other studio-mate, who probably speaks well for the Recovering Catholic demographic, responded with, "I don't like to talk about religion. I used to work at a convent and had to bring the nuns juice. They were some of the meanest people I've ever been around. Just cruel in the things they said." Ouch. I hope they appreciated that juice, deep down in their souls.
And then there's Sida, who is Buddhist and the most level-headed person I know. "Church should be a beautiful place of worship. Like the Basilica or the St. Paul Cathedral. So why do these people have to have a big-screen TV and do Karoke?"
All valid concerns, in my opinion.
If these new owners really want to connect with the community, as their website says, I am excited for them. If they want to keep up the comfortable vibe of Montana and remain a pillar of our growing neighborhood, I'd rather have them than another Dunn Brothers any day.
The most fruitful ministry they can provide is good coffee, comfortable furniture, good evening entertainment (Christian and non-Christian), beer and wine and, of course, the sourdough toast.
By not changing much, their "reward" as evangelicals might be to make new friends and possibly to share their lives in Christ with a few people who are curious. I believe "walking the walk" and not judging others is the true call of discipleship. If they do that, using their lives as examples of God's glory, people will take notice. If they serve tracts about abortion or sinfulness along with the coffee, it won't matter if they've got the best scones in town. People won't listen. People won't care. And people will stop coming immediately. There's a small window for success, based on how Christians are perceived in our culture. We've done a good portion of the damage ourselves.
As for me, I've decided I should be part of the solution. Maybe I'm in a unique position to help the new owners transition and also provide some of the services that they're interested in in a way that will attract and not alienate.
I'll send them an email offering my perspective and help. Maybe in exchange, I won't have to spend twenty bucks a day on coffee and toast. See, now that way, everybody wins!
I'll let you know what happens...